Cleopatra: History and Myth

 "…the last of the wise ones of Greece."

Al-Masúdí, Moroudj-al-dzeheb (10th century)

 

"Had Cleopatra’s nose been shorter, the face of the world would have been changed."

         Blaise Pascal, Pensées (1670)

 

"…the most complete woman ever to have existed, the most womanly woman and the most queenly queen, a person to be wondered at, to whom the poets have been able to add nothing, and whom dreamers always find at the end of their dreams."

                                                Théophile Gauthier, One of Cleopatra’s Nights (1845)

 

"How would you like to be the wickedest woman in history?"

                    Cecil B. DeMille, offering the role to Claudette Colbert for the 1934 movie

 

"I would have loved to have been Cleopatra in real life -- providing I could choose my own Antony."

Vivien Leigh, star of the 1951 movie

 

"The true history of Antony and Cleopatra will probably never be known; it is buried too deep beneath the version of the victors."

W.W. Tarn, The Battle of Actium (1931)

These quotations offer only a tiny fraction of the ideas that have been expressed about Cleopatra over the last 2000 years, for Cleopatra has exercised a hold over the imagination of people everywhere as no other woman has ever done. But who was Cleopatra?  Tarn’s comment may be the best answer we can give: her ‘true history’ may well be unknowable.  But the ways in which Cleopatra has been depicted over the centuries presents us with a more intriguing, and more interesting, question than that of who she really was. To the Romans, she was represented as the foreign queen who tried to steal their empire and who represented the most dangerous threat to their civilization in 200 years, but to the Egyptians she may have been a goddess incarnate, the universal mother, and a liberator who came to free them from oppression. Artists and writers since her death have not hesitated to offer their images of Cleopatra, as we shall see.  This course will examine these depictions of Cleopatra in a variety of different mediums to explore how each society has created their own image of this bewitching figure.

 

COURSE OBJECTIVES: 

The primary objective of this course is for first-year students to see the complexity that lies behind a seemingly simple topic, and to develop the enthusiasm for probing deeply into such subjects that will carry them into more advanced coursework.  Specifically students will learn:

COURSE FORMAT:

  As a First-Year Seminar, this class is intended to promote "significant intellectual exchange both between the instructor and the students and among the students." This will be a discussion-based class; very rarely will I lecture, and then only to provide background that I think is essential to our discussions. I see my role as that of coach and guide, trying to steer our discussions in a fruitful direction. Each student needs to assume the responsibility for being prepared to ask questions of myself and your fellow students, to offer answers to the questions of others, and to support the claims you are making.

Requirements:

You will EARN your grades in this course based on a variety of activities throughout the term. You should view each of these activities as an opportunity to impress upon the instructor your preparation and your knowledge of the material. I promise that I will fairly and thoroughly evaluate your work, but ultimately the grade you receive is based on the quality of work you do. Specifically, your term grade will be based on your performance in the following areas:

Collegiality (20%): In essence, this part of your grade is determined by how good a colleague you are to your fellow students. Among other things, collegiality may be demonstrated by: your on-time arrival and attendance at class; your completion of assigned readings before class; your presence in class throughout the entire class session; your active participation in all class activities; your attendance at the movies (see below), and your ability and willingness to master the course material in a creative and sophisticated manner. In particular, the collegiality portion of your grade will be based on the following course requirements:

Short Argumentative paper (20%):  Students will write one short (5-page) paper on a historical aspect of the career of Cleopatra.  Suggested paper topics will be distributed in class well before the due date, but students are free to choose their own topic in consultation with the instructor.

Research Paper (50%):  Each student will write a 10-12 page paper that explores the representation of Cleopatra in more detail.  Students will develop these papers on their own in consultation with the professor, beginning with a prospectus and bibliography, and including the submission of an outline in addition to the final draft, which will be due on November 26.  Loosely speaking these papers might pursue one of two paths. Students might  1) explore a particular time period and its representations of Cleopatra in two or more genres (fiction, drama, poetry, art, history): Is there a consistent image of Cleopatra that appears across the different genres?  If there are differences, where do they emerge and what might account for those differences? Alternatively, students might 2) explore a particular ‘type’ of Cleopatra (for instance, using Hughes-Hallett's categories, the Queen, the Lover, the Killer, the Suicide, the Foreigner, the Woman, the Child)  as represented in two or more time periods: What accounts for the same image appearing in two different time periods?  What did those societies have in common that they chose to emphasize the same aspects of Cleopatra's life and personality?  Are there any differences in how those societies used these ‘types’ and what might account for them?

Final Essay (10%): Over the course of the semester we will be encountering many different narratives of the life of Cleopatra. At the end of the semester, each student will be asked to compose his or her own narrative, using whatever format the students chooses and emphasizing whatever aspects of Cleopatra’s character seem most significant to that student. This narrative will be due on the final day of classes; there will be no final exam.

 

Grading Standards:

   

Requirements summary:

 

93-100

A

Outstanding

Collegiality:

200 points

90-93

A-

Excellent

Short Paper:

200 points

87-90

B+

Very Good

Long Paper:

500 points

83-87

B

Good

      Topic

 

80-83

B-

Above Average

      Biliography/Prospectus

 

77-80

C+

Satisfactory

      Draft

 

73-77

C

Adequate

      Final Submission

 

70-73

C-

Barely Adequate

Final Essay:

100 points

60-70

D

Poor

   

<60

F

Failure

   

 

 

Please note the following general policies.

 

COURSE SCHEDULE AND ASSIGNMENTS:

 Week 1 Introduction & Background
Sept. 3 Course Introduction
Sept. 5 Cleopatras Whitehorne, Preface and pp. 1-13
Assignment: Find a Cleopatra!
Week 2 Antecedents
Sept. 8 The Hellenistic World Whitehorne, 57-79
*Theocritus, Idyll 17
*M. Grant, From Alexander to Cleopatra, 1-20
Sept. 10 Hellenistic Queens Whitehorne 80-88, 149-173
Sept. 12 Women in Greece and Rome Lefkowitz & Fant, Women’s Life in Greece & Rome
Online Selections 43, 53, 101, 111, 112, 132,148, 168, 173, 176, 178, 208, 242, 253, 267

NB: The link above takes you to the table of contents for the text; you need to click on sections II, IV, V, VI, and VII to find the appropriate readings for class.

Week 3 Cleopatra’s World: Egypt & Rome
Sept. 15 Ptolemaic Egypt *F. Walbank, The Hellenistic World 113-120
*Catullus, Poem 66
Whitehorne 89-120
Sept. 17 Isis *G. Holbl, History of the Ptolemaic Empire 271-289
Whitehorne 121-131
Sept. 19 Rome the world power *Beard & Crawford, Rome in the Late Republic
Week 4 Cleopatra’s Life and Times
Sept. 22 Cleopatra and Caesar *Suetonius, Julius Caesar, 35, 45-54
*Plutarch, Julius Caesar 48-49
*Cicero, Selected Letters
    MOVIE: Cleopatra (1963), starring Elizabeth Taylor and Richard Burton (Part I)
Sept. 24 Cleopatra and Antony, Part I *Plutarch, Mark Antony 1-39
Sept. 26 Cleopatra and Antony, Part II *Plutarch, Mark Antony 40-87
Week 5   The War with Rome:  Propaganda & Politics 
Sept. 29 Augustan Ideology *P. Zanker, The Power of Images, 44-65
*Suetonius, Augustus, 9-16, 68-71
    MOVIE: Cleopatra (1963), starring Elizabeth Taylor and Richard Burton (Part II)
Oct. 1 The Battle of Actium *Cassius Dio 50.1-35
*Suetonius, Augustus, 17-23, 51-65
*Horace, Epode 9
Oct. 3 The Suicide of Cleopatra *Cassius Dio 51.1-51.17
Whitehorne 186-196
Week 6 Poetic Cleopatras
Oct. 6 NO CLASS – Yom Kippur
Oct. 7 TUESDAY: First Paper Due                 Wyatt 149, 5:00 p.m.
Oct. 8 Virgilian Cleopatras *Virgil, Aeneid, tr. Fitzgerald
Selections from Books 1, 4, 6, 8
Oct. 10 Augustan Cleopatras *Horace, Ode 1.37
*Propertius 3.11
*M. Wyke, "Augustan Cleopatras"
Topic for Research Paper Due
Week 7 Imperial Cleopatras
Oct. 13 LIBRARY DAY MEET IN LIBRARY
   MOVIE: Cleopatra (1934), starring Claudette Colbert and Harry Wilcoxen
Oct. 15 A Post-Augustan Cleopatra  *Lucan, Pharsalia Book 10
Oct. 17 Plutarch Deconstructed Reread Plutarch, Antony
Week 8 Post-Augustan Cleopatras
Oct. 20 NO CLASS – Fall Break
Oct. 22 Later Antiquity *Aurelius Victor, On Illustrious Men 86
*Pliny, Natural History
*Philostratus, Lives of the Sophists
Bibliography and 1-Page Outline Due
Oct. 24 Cleopatra: Sinner or Saint? *Chaucer, Legend of Good Women
*Boccaccio, On Famous Women
Week 9 Elizabethan England
Oct. 27 Shakespeare’s Cleopatra I Antony and Cleopatra, Act I
   MOVIE: Antony & Cleopatra (1974), starring Janet Suzman and Richard Johnson
Oct. 29 Shakespeare’s Cleopatra II Antony and Cleopatra, Acts II and III
Oct. 31 Shakespeare’s Cleopatra III Antony and Cleopatra, Acts IV and V
     Feel free to consult the Guthrie Theater's Study Guide to Antony and Cleopatra for ideas to ponder.
Week 10 Restoration England
Nov. 3 Dryden’s Cleopatra I All for Love, Act I
Nov. 5 Dryden’s Cleopatra II All for Love, Acts II and III
Nov. 7 Dryden’s Cleopatra III All for Love, Acts IV & V
Week 11 The 18th century
Nov. 10  Paperwork!  Rough Draft of Paper Due
Nov. 12  Cleopatra:One Woman's View *S. Fielding, Life of Cleopatra
Nov. 14   Octavia, Paragon of Virtue? *S. Fielding, Life of Octavia
Week 12  Orientalism
Nov. 17   Cleopatra the Seductress
*Th. Gauthier, One of Cleopatra's Nights
*
A. Swinburne, "Cleopatra"
Nov. 19   Cleopatra the Foreigner *H. R. Haggard, Cleopatra, pp. 70-121 of reader
Nov. 21   Cleopatra the Exotic *H. R. Haggard, Cleopatra, pp. 121-168 of reader
Week 13
Nov. 24   Cleopatra the Killer *H. R. Haggard, Cleopatra, pp. 168-217 of reader
   MOVIE: Cleopatra (1999), starring Leonor Varela and Billy Zane
Nov. 26 Research Paper Due
Nov. 28 - NO CLASS No Class - Thanksgiving
Week 14 Victorian England
Dec. 1  Cleopatra as Teenager Shaw, Caesar and Cleopatra, Act I
Dec. 3  Cleopatra as Vixen Shaw, Caesar and Cleopatra, Acts II and III
Dec. 10 Cleopatra as Vamp Shaw, Caesar and Cleopatra, Acts IV & V
Week 15 21st Century Cleopatras
Dec. 8 Where does Cleopatra go from here? *L. Hughes-Hallett, Cleopatra, 295-307
      MOVIE: Caesar and Cleopatra (1945), starring Vivien Leigh and Claude Rains
Dec. 10 Wrapup and party Final Essay Due

 

BIBLIOGRAPHY:

See also the webpage created by Peggy Burge as a research gateway for this course.

Abbott, Jacob. History of Cleopatra, Queen of Egypt (1852)
Adelman, Janet. The Common Liar, an essay on Antony and Cleopatra (1973)
Aurelius Victor, On the Lives of Illustrious Men (~300)
Bianchi, Robert. Cleopatra’s Egypt: Age of the Ptolemies (1988)
Bocaccio, Giovanni. On Famous Women (1362)             
Brandon, Samuel. The Tragicomoedi of the vertuous Octavia (1598)
Bronte, Charlotte. Villette (1853)
Brooke, Henry. Antony and Cleopatra (1778)
Butts, Mary, Scenes from the Life of Cleopatra (1935)
Chase-Ribaud, Barbara, "Portrait of a Nude Woman as Cleopatra" (1987)
Chaucer, On the Lives of Good Women (1380)
Cibber, Colley. Caesar in Egypt: a tragedy (1725)
Cicero, Letters (~50 BCE)
Cixous, Hélène and Clément, Catherine. The Newly Born Woman (1986)
Clark, Mary, "Cleopatra’s Soliloquy" (19th cent.)
Corneille, Pierre, The Death of Pompey (1643)
D’Arienzo, Marco. Cleopatra (1875)

Daniel, Samuel. The Tragedie of Cleopatra (1594)

de Barnáth, Désiré. Cleopatra: her Life and Reign (1901)
de Girardin, Delphine. Cléopâtre (1847)
Delayen, Gaston. Cleopatra (1934)
Dio Cassius, Roman History (~220 CE)
Dryden, John.  All for Love (1678)
Ebers, Georg. Cleopatra, A Romance (1894)
Ellis, Oliver Coligny de Champfleur. Cleopatra in the Tide of Time (1947)
Feld, Bruce. Cleopatra in the Night and Other Poems (1999)
Ferval, Claude (pseudonym), The Private Life of Cleopatra (1930)
Fielding, Sarah, The Lives of Cleopatra and Octavia (1757)
Flamarion, Edith.  Cleopatra, The Life and Death of a Pharoah (1997)
Foss, Michael. The Search for Cleopatra (1987)
Gautier, Theophile, One night with Cleopatra (1845)
George, Margaret. The Memoirs of Cleopatra: A Novel (1997)
Haggard, H. Rider, Cleopatra (1889)
Hamer, Mary, Signs of Cleopatra (1993)

Haskell, Francis and Penny, Nicholas, Taste and the Antique (1981)

Herbert, Mary, Antonie (translation of R. Garnier Marc Antoine) (1592)

Herbery, Henry W. "Cleopatra" (1807-1858)
Horace, Odes (~20 BCE)
Houssaye, Henri. Cleopatra, A Study (1890)
Hughes-Hallett, Lucy, Cleopatra: Histories, Dreams and Distortions (1990)
Ironmonger, C. Edith. Cleopatra, A Narrative Poem (1924)

La Calpranede, Gautier de Costes, Cleopatre 12 vols. (1647-1658)

Lindsay, V. "The Trial of the Dead Cleopatra in her Beautiful and Wonderful Tomb" (1923)
Lucan, Pharsalia (~70 CE)
Mackereth, James A. The Death of Cleopatra, A DRAMATIC POEM (1920)
May, Thomas. The Tragedie of Cleopatra Queen of Egypt (1639)
Mundy, Talbot. Queen Cleopatra (1929)
Nott, Vernon. Cleopatra with Antony, A Poetic Dialogue (1904)

O’Shaughnessy, Arthur, An Epic of Women and Other Poems (1870)

Pliny the Elder, Natural History (~60 CE)
Plutarch, Lives(~120 CE)

Pomeroy, Sarah. Goddesses, Whores, Wives, and Slaves (1975)

Propertius, Elegies (~20 BCE)
Pushkin, Aleksandr. Egyptian Nights (1837)

Saadeh, Khalil, Caesar and Cleopatra (1898)

Said, Edward. Orientalism (1978)

Sedley, Charles. Antony and Cleopatra, a Tragedy (1677)

Shakespeare, William.  Antony and Cleopatra (1607)

Shaw, George Bernard. Caesar and Cleopatra (1889)

Simms, William G. "The Death of Cleopatra" (1853)
Stadelmann, Heinrich. Cleopatra, Egypt’s Last Queen (1924)
Stahr, Adolph. Cleopatra (1864)
Stevenson, Robert Louis. "After Reading ‘Antony and Cleopatra’" (1850-1894)

Swinburne, Algernon. Cleopatra (1866)

Symons, Arthur. Cleopatra (1916)
Tyrwhitt-Wilson, Gerald. The Romance of a Nose (1941)
Velleius Paterculus, History (~30 CE)
Virgil, Aeneid (~19 BCE)
Volkmann, Heinrich, Cleopatra: a Study in Politics and Propaganda (1958)
von Wertheimer, Oskar. Cleopatra – a Royal Voluptuary (1931)
Walbank, Frank W.  The Hellenistic Age (1981)

Walker, Susan and Higgs, Peter, Cleopatra of Egypt: From History to Myth (2001)

Wilder, Thornton. The Ides of March (1948)
Wyke, Maria. Projecting the Past (1997)

 

ARTISTIC REPRESENTATIONS:

(1st c. BCE) bas-relief of Cleopatra & Caesarion from temple at Kom Ombo, Egypt
(400’s) Fresco of the death of Cleopatra in Roman catacomb
(1405), The Suicide of Cleopatra (illustrating manuscript of Bocaccio)
(1473) Johann Zainer, Cleopatra’s Banquet & the Suicides of Antony and Cleopatra
(1500’s) Sardonyx Cameos portraying the suicide of Cleopatra
(1520) Giampetrino, Cleopatra
(1523) Jean van Scorel, The dying Cleopatra
(1533-34) Michelangelo, Head of Cleopatra
(16th c.) Giulio Clovio, Cleopatra
(16th c.) Florentine school, Cleopatra
(1622-24) Johann Liss, The Death of Cleopatra
(1630's) Giovanni Barbieri (Guercino), Cleopatra
(1630’s) Massimo Stanzione, Cleopatra
(1635), Alessandro Turchi, The Death of Antony and Cleopatra
(1639) Guido Reni, Cleopatra
(1643), Pietro da Cortona, Caesar Restores the Throne of Egypt to Cleopatra
(1642-43) Claude Lorrain, The Disembarkation of Cleopatra at Tarsus
(1643-57), Claude Vignon (Le Vieux), The Death of Cleopatra
(1648) Giovanni Barbieri (Guercino), The Death of Cleopatra
(1653) Jacob Jordaens, Cleopatra's Feast
(1658) Jan de Bray, The de Bray Family (The Banquet of Antony & Cleopatra)
(1658) Guido Cagnacci, The Death of Cleopatra
   
see also this painting of two years later - The Death of Cleopatra (1660) 
(1680) Gerard de Lairesse, Cleopatra's Banquet 
(17th c.) Frans Francken the Younger, Cleopatra Disembarking at Tarsus
(1700) Antonio Bellucci, The Death of Cleopatra
(1700's)  Gerard Hoet, The Banquet of Cleopatra
(1702) Francesco Trevisani, The Banquet of Mark Antony
(1746-47) Giambattista Tiepolo, Banquet of Antony and Cleopatra (Palazzo Labia)
(1746-47) Giambattista Tiepolo, Meeting of Antony and Cleopatra
(1748) John Parker, The Death of Cleopatra
(1759) Anton Raphael Mengs, Augustus & Cleopatra
(1770) Angelica Kauffman, Cleopatra decorating the tomb of Antony
(1774) Louis-Jean-Francois Lagrenée, The Death of Cleopatra
(1838) E. Delacroix, Cleopatra and the Peasant
(1838-1845) Francis Stephanoff, Antony Taking Leave of Cleopatra
(1866) Frederick Sandys, Cleopatra
(1866) Jean-Leon Gerome, Cleopatra and Caesar
(1874) Jean-Andre Rixens, The Death of Cleopatra
(1875?)Valentine Prinsep, The Death of Cleopatra
(1880) Georges Rochegrosse, Cleopatra and Her Attendants
(1885) Lawrence Alma-Tadema, Antony and Cleopatra
(1887) Alexander Cabanel, Cleopatra trying poisons on condemned prisoners
(1887) Gustave Moreau, Cleopatra
(1892) R. Arthur, The Suicide Of Cleopatra
(1896?) Frederick Bridgman, Cleopatra’s Funeral Barge
(19th c.) Louis-Marie Baader, The Death of Cleopatra
(19th c.) T. Buchanan, The Embarcation of Cleopatra
(20th c.), S. Daynes-Grassot, Cleopatra Testing her Poisons on her Slaves